10 Best Handmade Puppets 2025

Step right up and get ready to meet the stars of your next puppet show! We've scoured the market for the best handmade puppets in the Toys & Games category, and after extensive research and testing, we're excited to present to you our top 10 picks. From customizable characters to professional quality, we reviewed and scored products in this category ranging from a 7.2 all the way up to a 9.9 - and our highest scorer just so happens to come from the one and only Puppedcation. Their Customizable Boy Puppet #1 is the perfect addition to any puppet ministry, school, or church program. But don't just take our word for it - dive into our comprehensive reviews to find the perfect handmade puppet for your next performance!